Gems and Gemology. Gems Scams: A Little More Than a Hoax

Article author: Mª Dolores Sánchez Polledo Article published at: Jun 17, 2020 Article comments count: 1 comment
Gems and Gemology. Gems Scams: A Little More Than a Hoax

This morning, on a Facebook, I read something that filled me a flow of memories.

My name is Lola Sanchez, I'm a gemologist and the owner of MdMaya Gems, but before that, I was a buyer. Not a "professional" buyer or collector, that came afterwards, but just a simple buyer.

What I am about to tell you happened more than 25 years ago in Palma de Mallorca, while I was living there, I didn't understand absolutely nothing about gems and gemology. It began at a jewellery store, where there was a gorgeous ring with a big blue stone in the window. I went in to have a better look at the stone, and asked them what the stone was, to which they replied, “An aquamarine”. I never wear rings, so I asked them to make me a pendant with the stone. The rest of the story is very simple - two years later I discovered it was a synthetic spinel.

"The Guilty"
The "Guilty"

 

Since that day, I can assure you that I have bought just about everything. I often buy items knowing that they are not what they claim them to be, but curiosity takes over, and at other times they try to trick me. But this is not what I want to tell you about right now.

Once I knew that the pendant's stone was a synthetic spinel it was completely cast aside. Even today I still remember the unpleasant feeling I had, and not because I had financial problems, or because of the money I spent buying it, it is about disappointment.

synthetic ruby
This synthetic ruby is over 6 ct, it was advertised as natural and its price was ridiculous, so I could not resist, it was obviously synthetic.

 

When you are a gemologist, very often friends and people who you really love and appreciate bring you stones to look at, frequently mounted in jewellery pieces.

The relationship that we humans have with gems and jewels is very curious. For us they are treasures, treasures that we want to take with us to the beyond, just as the Pharaohs did, or they are a legacy we want to leave so our memory lives on. Often we leave these treasures to our children thinking that they will help them in times of trouble, and it is for this reason that we will even risk our life for those treasures.

But they are not only treasures, they are also feelings; we give them to each other on special occasions, for weddings, engagements, births, birthdays, etc., and sometimes these gifts, these gems and jewels, have a special meaning or they remind us of someone very special.

Roman gold wedding-ring set with a stone of aquamarine. The names Valerianus and Paterna are inlaid in niello around the edges of the ring 300 AC. Source British Museum

 

Many years ago a person that I really love, a great friend of mine and above all a very good person, brought me some blue stones set in silver. She said to me: "Please take a look at these aquamarines, they were my mother's and I want to do something with them for my sisters to have a nice memory of our mother". At first glance, like gemologist, they looked like they were topazes. The stones were mounted in silver and had a blue tone, but had they been aquamarines they would never have been mounted in silver. In effect, the refractive index of the gems made it very clear - Topaz. When I broke the news to her, her disappointed and grieved look made me feel really bad, I was the bearer of bad news. And I bet my life that she never did do anything with them nor gave them to her sisters, and that they were relegated to the drawer of oblivion.

Not long ago my sister told me: "Look at these earrings that belonged to our aunt". They proved to be gold earrings with some beautiful Verneuil sapphires. Some "wonderful" curved growth lines could be seen.

So the last time someone I love very much, my mother, said to me: "Look at this ring that Dad gave me", -my father had already passed away-, I kissed her and just simply did not want to look at it.

Article author: Mª Dolores Sánchez Polledo Article published at: Jun 17, 2020

1 comments

Emma

This is so true. It reminds me of a time when this lovely lady gemologist I know sent me a gift with a purchase I made, and along with it a beautiful email.

I had earrings made with what she sent me and every time I wear them it makes me smile because I think of her kindness. I have gems which are incredibly valuable in monetary terms but those earrings are amongst my favourite pieces of jewellery 😊

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published